Help

In The Klingon Dictionary, the verb "help" is translated as boQ assist and QaH help while the difference is not so exactly defined. In a later message – see below – Okrand explained that in general, the difference is that QaH is used to help someone in a situation which they could not solve alone ("Help! I can't swim!"), while boQ is used in a support situation which is easier to solve when two or more people do it ("Help me carry this heavy box").

Canon examples

From Conversational Klingon:
nom QaH yIqem. Get help quickly!
.
HIDjolev Dayaj'a', tera'ngan? Do you understand the menu, Terran?
ghobe'. HIboQ. No. Help me.

Klingon for the Galactic Traveler does not mention boQ, but has a few phrases with QaH, although those do not reveal any information on their usage. There are no examples for these words in The Klingon Way.

Canon clarification

In a Facebook message to Jeremy Cowan, Marc Okrand explained the difference: (1)

Regarding QaH and boQ – There's a good deal of overlap, and either one can be used in many (maybe most) situations. The main difference is really one of connotation. In general, QaH would be used in situations where the person needing help can't do whatever needs to be done without assistance of some kind, while boQ would be used in situations where the person might be able to do the task alone, but it's easier or better or more efficient if someone helps out.

The object of boQ (the recipient of the aid) retains responsibility for the activity being aided. The person boQ-ing is secondary (though not necessarily unimportant!).

The object of QaH can't do whatever it is alone, so responsibility falls to the person QaH-ing (or responsibility is shared).

Someone who falls into a river and is unable to swim would not shout out HIboQ!.

Someone who can't reach the top shelf would probably ask another person for boQ to get something down from the shelf (even though the task could be done alone if the person used a stepladder or stool or something). If the person tried it alone and boxes toppled down from the top shelf onto the person, immobilizing him/her, you'd probably hear the buried person ask for QaH.

It would be odd to use QaHwI' to refer to an administrative aide; that's a boQ.

A parent probably wouldn't QaH a child with a homework assignment.

There is nothing weak about asking for QaH (when help is warranted), but an offer to QaH in a situation where you'd expect to hear an offer to boQ may sometimes be mildly insulting, implying that the offerer questions the offeree's ability to do something.

Having said all of that... The distinction is not always clear nor does it always matter, which is why the words are mostly interchangeable.

"Assist" would probably be translated as boQ most of the time. Other than in a few contexts, both "help" and "aid" could be translated as either boQ or QaH.

(David's boQwI' app is aptly named.)

See also

  • boQwI', the "Klingon Assistant", a vocabulary look-up app

References

1 : Message by Okrand to Jeremy Cowan, Facebook, published 17 Oct 2017

External links

Category: Vocabulary    Latest edit: 26 Mar 2018, by KlingonTeacher    Created: 21 Mar 2018 by KlingonTeacher
 
The Klingon Language Wiki is a private fan project to promote the Klingon language. See Copyright notice for details.