Appearances of Klingon: on television - in movies - in the news - in commercials - in politics - in literature - Translations

Homlet: Prince of Kronos (The Hard Bone Blues)

Homlet (Hom let "hard bone")(1) is the title of Glen Proechel's translation of Hamlet, translated in 1995 (2). In an open letter to the mailing list, KLI director Lawrence M. Schoen made clear that this work is not a part of the KLI's KSRP (3).

To understand the existence of two seperate translations, one should know that Proechel had different opinions on treating the Klingon language than members of the Klingon Language Institute (KLI) did, for instance creating neologisms by himself breaking grammatical rules.

The translation has never been published, although some copies may have been distributed, since one is listed in the Susan Frank Collection. It is very unlikely to be a good translation. Proechel did it all by himself, in just a couple of weeks. Even if he could speak proper Klingon - which he didn't - one would not expect much from such a hasty work. The KLI's translation of Hamlet, on the other hand, has been done by several experts of Klingon; proofread, edited and revised for more than a year before it was published. (4)

See also

References

1 : Message to the mailing list, by Steven Boozer, 26 Dec 2007

2 : qIb HeHDaq, an Internet edition of the journal of the Interstellar Language School

3 : To The Klingon Community, Lawrence M. Schon, 24 Oct 1995

4 : http://www.datapacrat.com/Art/Fiction/STARTREK/KLING/LANGUAGE.HTM, written before 1996, Retrieved 16 Feb 2017

Category: Appearance    Latest edit: 16 Feb 2017, by KlingonTeacher    Created: 16 Feb 2017 by KlingonTeacher



MessageToKronos
On the occasion of the first Klingon opera 'u' which premiered in 2010 ...
CompoundNounsWithAVerb
This page lists nouns that are preceded by a suffixed verb. The purpose ...
CarletonCopeland
Carleton Copeland ( Klingon Name : qa'ral) ist a Klingonist from ...

Day of the week:
Today is DaSjaj


starred Random Article


  • Search

Other languages:

flag_en.png English
flag_de.png Deutsch
flag_nl.png Create New Topic
flag_fr.png Create New Topic

Visit us on Facebook:

 
The Klingon Wiki - Teaching Klingon to the galaxy

All text is available under the terms of a Creative Commons License.
Star Trek™, Klingon™ and related names are trademarks of CBS Corporation and Paramount Pictures, and are used under "fair use" guidelines.